230 E 58th St / 3rd Ave, 212.339.0090
[
Map][
Citysearch][
MenuPages][
Website]
Cost per person: $40
"YGWYPF" factor: 8.5/10 (you get what you pay for)
Food: 8.5/10
Ambiance: 9/10
Yash and
Chhordibhai (
Madhumita) decided to give
Soma a graduation treat at
Yuva, and I got to tag along. 53rd between 2
nd and 3rd is
jam packed with really nice, upscale Indian places - there's this, of course, as well as
Dawat, and
Chola, and Ada. All in one block. Must have the highest per-square-foot consumption of
Taj Mahal beer in the entire United States (assuming the cheaper, and less elite, places down on Curry Hill -
Lex and 20's - have their
clientele order mostly water, no ice).
This is a smaller place than
Madhur Jaffrey's Dawat, but a rather cozy one. Just don't click on their website - it's a horrible mess of Flash animations, the kind that forces you to wait for animations to finish before you can click. Reservations are a must - and I'm glad to say ours was right on time, if not a little early.
This being one of the rare
occasions with more than just the two of us at a table, we had a little more leeway in terms of entrees. For starters, the [
Kakori Kabaab minced baby lamb flavored with fresh herbs, cardamom, mace & grilled] was really well made - soft, yet
tandoored to a perfection. For entrees - [
Chicken Tikka Masala roasted chicken simmered in a rich tomato cream sauce, accented with fenugreek leaves] was right as expected, and a little better than the same at most other places. The [
Paneer Tikka Masala roasted paneer cheese cubes spiced in herbs & slow cooked in crushed tomato cream sauce] was exactly the same, with large cubes of
paneer instead of chicken. The [
Parda Biryani spiced basmati rice slow cooked in a casserole covered with dough to seal the moisture & aroma of the spices. our specialty.] was mysteriously missing the full definition - as well as the option to spike it up with seafood or goat (other options: veg, chicken or lamb) - in one of our menus. Their menu version control probably needs a looking into. The
biryani was very well presented - in a clay pot sealed with a tandoori
roti - and was very flavorful, though my bias still rests with
Kabab King Diner. The most notable mention of our dinner was the [
Chicken Kali Mirch boneless chunks of marinated chicken slow cooked with peppercorn, in a spicy onion & garlic sauce] - the innovative flavor was a very welcome change from having seen the same menu over and over at all Indian places, and definitely makes this menu stand out, if only by a little bit.